There was so much to love about this book, and yet, a few things that really detracted for me. I'll start with what I liked.

First of all, George and Fred are my heroes! Their roles in the story has grown throughout the books, starting out as just some background troublemakers. But in this book, their mischief found a target, and it was brilliant. After so long of Umbridge being one of the most despised characters I've ever read/seen, the culmination of George and Fred sticking it to her was almost worth it (but not really). Not to mention Peeves taking up the call.

I liked seeing Lupin again and loved seeing so much of Sirius. In my review of the previous book, I mentioned how much I liked him being around so much in that one, and his role was even bigger in this one. He's become my favorite character, which I think may be as much because of what he's able to be to Harry as anything. Of course, that just made it all the worse at the end. I am frustrated about the fact that Hermione actually did question if it could be a trap, only for them to take the word of the house elf and walk into the trap anyway. But I'm not sure if my frustration about his death is just because I liked him or if I'm legitimately bugged by what seems like a spot of weak plotting/characterization.

I also really liked the progression of the D.A. and Harry trying to explain that a lot of what he'd done in the past was luck. Yet they were aware that, luck or not, he still had more practice with these spells than anyone else. I was glad to see Neville have some good moments in this book, while still having plenty of struggles, poor kid.

There were some other smaller things that happened that I found particularly interesting, like Ron being made prefect and the reminder that Petunia would have at least a little knowledge of magic. Hermione's drive for house elf freedom can die any time, in my opinion. But who knows, maybe it'll have a purpose at some point in the last couple of books.

The biggest downside to this book is Umbridge herself, and how much power she's given by the end of the book, only to not really have a great resolution to it. And really, it's not Umbridge, at least not solely, but the Ministry, and how much power they are able to wield with apparently no one to keep them in check. Because of how long the book was, this whole thing just seemed to drag on and on.

As for the book length...I have never been one for long books. Never read anything longer than 550 pages, and that length is not common for me. But of course, I didn't come this far to not finish the series. After reading it, though, I can see a few side plots that could have been cut out. Of course, I don't know that these side plots won't be more important in the later books, so maybe I'm wrong.

Things are getting real now, and there are only 2 books left. I'm so nervous about what other bad things will happen as this series finishes up (not to mention about spoilers I've heard out of context). ( )

9/10, what a masterpiece, I might read this again later. ( )

Yep. ( )

Excelente, como siempre. Super sorprendida ya que al haber visto solamente las películas, muchas dudas se resolvieron al leerlo. ( )

I know I'm in the minority for only giving this three stars. But I don't know how I can give it more. The world-building is still first rate. There is enough story and character development here for a five-star read. The problem is that it's well hidden inside of an overblown, over-sized book where nothing much happens for pages and pages. Yes, it's often fascinating and I did make it to the end. And the end is where it all becomes worth the while. But it was a bit of a slog.

Knock off a half a star just for being so long. Editing, people, editing. Knock off another half star for quite a few clinks and clunks in the writing. Adverbs, he said, disapprovingly. These are the same issues that started creeping in with the previous volume.

Now knock off a full star for story-killing character traits. Harry is just too much of a dunderhead in this. I understand that one of the main themes is his growing teenage angst. It just was not done well. He was argumentative for the sake of being argumentative, often just because that would move the story forward. Not because it fit his character. Umbridge was evil just for the sake of being evil. We never found out what she was truly up to. Again, I felt cheated because it seemed that everything she did to make Harry's life harder was done merely because the story need her to do it. And what the heck is up with Dumbledore? He was just too aloof in this, swooping in at the odd moment to save the day in an odd way. At least he explains it all in the end.

Only two more books to go. I hope they don't feel like five. ( )